ARTIST: RQTN TITLE: We Were... We Are LABEL: Swarm of Nails Records GENRE: Instrumental Rock BITRATE: 205kbps avg PLAYTIME: 0h 39m total RELEASE DATE: 2008-06-00 RIP DATE: 2008-11-19 Track List ---------- 1. Morning And Handwritten Letter 7:52 2. Of Course... They All Died 8:35 3. She Left Me When I Was On The 6:04 Battlefield 4. All My Feelings Were Fake 8:42 5. Passing Out In Front Of Us 8:00 Release Notes: http://www.myspace.com/rqtnisdead RQTN was born from the ashes of the now-defunct French hardcore band, Atheist Prayer. Guitarist Mathieu Artu enlisted a few friends, including Gregory Hoepffner from Time to Burn, for this decidedly more downtempo affair. While RQTN is more relaxing than its parent band, this long EP (5 songs, 39 minutes) could have used a bit more of daddy’s fire. Granted, this is meant to be a post-rock/ambient production (and it’s nice to see someone actually define themselves as post-rock these days), but there’s nothing in the books that says it has to be so calm. Part of the problem may be the transition between genres, one which is easy to emulate, but hard to imitate. RQTN’s album and website imagery contains vestigial references to a more violent past. The dominant imagery is that of WWII: black and white photos of an anguished soldier, a worried mother looking skyward, a boat discharging soldiers at Normandy. And yet the music fails to conjure up the requisite subject matter or emotion, presenting a soothing patina when we expected a requiem. Only the first track, “Morning and Handwritten Letters,” comes close, but as such, it might have worked better as a closing track. This former TSB Track of the Week is well-deserving of accolades. The song is anchored by a recurrent five-note xylophone theme, supported by a three-note violin theme and some highly effective military drums, reminiscent of Larry Mullen’s work on U2’s The Joshua Tree. Simple, but it works. After this fantastic opener, the EP begins to nod into a post-rock nap, the ideas coming slower as the tunes progress. “Of Course, They All Died” is the album’s second track and second-best song. This track is what most would call “typical post-rock,” a languid series of peaks and valleys culminating in a subdued crescendo. The accompanying video contains some nice footage of canyons and clouds in fast-forward, followed by scenes of streetwalks and cars, a la Koyaanisqatsi, and concludes with clouds moving over a city of electric lights. This is all very appealing, but unfortunately, it’s familiar ground. Perhaps all novices in the post-rock field need to start this way, testing the template before expanding their horizons. The third track is the third-best song, the fourth is the fourth-best, and the fifth – you guessed it – is the most disposable. Track three, “She Left Me When I Was on the Battlefield,” offers piano over a light rainstorm (again, a cliché, but a nice cliché). I suppose we are supposed to feel sorry for the poor soldier, but the music just doesn’t sound that sad. Most folks would just call it pretty. “All My Feelings Were Fake” features an ambient guitar with slight reverb. We’ll call this one “pleasant.” The closer, “Passing Out in Front of Us,” features competent but unnecessary vocals. All of this makes one want to play the opening track once more to remind ourselves of how good RQTN can be. Artu and company are certainly talented, and this is an above-average release, but the music and the subject matter are at odds, and the disparity is somewhat worrisome. Perhaps in this digital age, it is incongruous to quibble about imagery when reviewing an audio release, but some images are so powerful that they create an aura of expectation, and the music here simply does not fulfill it. Worth the six euros for those who live in Europe, others should decide based on their pay scale.